Cigar Aficionado Cigar of the Year 2014
Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado
Cigar Aficionado - February 2015
96 Oliva Serie V Special Edition 2012 Diadema Cigar Journal Winter 2013
96 Oliva Serie V Melanio Gran Reserva Limitada Churchill Cigar Affection November 2013
95 Oliva Serie V Melanio Cigar Snob Jan/Feb 2013
95 Oliva Serie V Melanio Cigar Snob December 2012
94 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Torpedo Cigar Snob Jan/Feb 2014
94 Oliva Serie O Chruchill Cigar Aficionado January 2014
94 Oliva Serie O Chruchill Cigar Aficionado December 2013
94 Oliva Serie V Melanio Chruchill Cigar Jornal Summer 2013
94 Oliva Serie V Torpedo Cigar Aficionado December 2007
94 Oliva Serie V Torpedo Cigar Insider October 2007
94 Oliva Serie V Torpedo Cigar Insider September 2007
93 Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado Cigar Aficionado December 2014
93 Oliva Serie V No. 4 Cigar Snob July/August 2014
93 Oliva Serie V Melanio Double Toro Cigar Journal Summer 2014
93 Oliva Serie V No. 4 Cigar Snob Mar/April 2014
93 Oliva Serie V 6x56 Cigar & Spirits Mar/April 2014
93 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Torpedo Cigar Snob Sept/Oct 2013
93 Oliva Serie V Maduro Especial Toro Cigar Snob July/August 2013
93 Oliva Serie V Maduro Especial Cigar Snob Oct/Nov 2010
93 Oliva Serie V Double Robusto Cigar Snob July/Aug 2010
93 Cigar Aficionado's Best Cigar of 2007 Cigar Snob February 2008
92 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Churchill Cigar Aficionado March 2015
92 Oliva Serie G Cameroon Churchill Cigar Snob Sept/Oct 2014
92 Oliva Serie V Torpedo Cigar Aficionado January 2014
92 Oliva Serie V Double Robusto Cigar Insider October 2013
92 Oliva Serie V Torpedo Cigar Insider October 2013
92 Oliva Serie O Churchill Cigar Aficionado August 2013
92 Oliva Master Blends 3 Robusto Cigar Snob May/June 2013
92 Oliva Serie V Melanio No. 4 Cigar Journal Spring 2013
92 Oliva Serie V Melanio Cigar Aficionado February 2013
92 Cigar Aficionado's Best Cigars of 2012 Cigar Aficionado February 2013
92 Oliva Master Blends 3 Cigar Snob Oct/Nov 2010
92 Oliva Serie V Liga Especial Cigar Snob Mar/Apr 2010
92 Oliva Serie V Churchill Cigar Snob February 2010
92 Oliva Serie V Double Robusto Cigar Aficionado February 2009
92 Oliva Serie V Double Robusto Cigar Aficionado April 2008
92 Oliva Serie V Double Robusto Cigar Insider September 2007
92 Oliva Sere G Robusto
(formally Oliva Grand Cameroon)
Cigar Aficionado Febrary 2007
92 Oliva Master Blend 3 Robusto Cigar Insider November 2006
92 Oliva "O" Classic Olé #9 - Cigar Aficionado Best Cigars of the Year 2005 Cigar Aficionado Febrary 2007
92 Oliva Grand Cameroon Belicoso Cigar Insider March 2006
92 Oliva "O" Classic Olé Cigar Aficionado August 2005
91 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Cigar Journal Winter 2014
91 Oliva Connecticut Reserve Cigar Snob May/June 2014
91 Oliva Connecticut Reserve Cigar Snob Jan/Feb 2014
91 Oliva Serie V Lancero Cigar Aficionado November 2013
91 Oliva Serie V Lancero Cigar Insider October 2013
91 Oliva Serie G Cameroon Churchill Cigar Snob July/August 2013
91 Oliva Serie O Churchill Cigar Snob May/June 2013
91 Oliva Conneticut Reserve Cigar Snob Mar/Apr 2013
91 Oliva Conneticut Reserve Cigar Snob Dec/Jan 2011
91 Oliva Conneticut Reserve Cigar Snob May/June 2010
91 Oliva Serie G Cameroon Cigar Snob July/Aug 2009
91 Oliva Master Blend 3 Torpedo Cigar Aficionado August 2007
91 Oliva Master Blend 3 Double Robusto Cigar Insider November 2006
91 Oliva Master Blend 3 Torpedo Cigar Insider November 2006
91 Oliva Grand Cameroon Robusto Cigar Insider March 2006
91 Oliva "O" Classic Olé Cigar Insider June 2005
91 Oliva Master Blend 2 Robusto Cigar Insider October 2005
90 Oliva Serie V Maduro Especial 2009 Torpedo Cigar Journal Spring 2014
90 Oliva Serie V Special V Figurado Cigar Insider October 2013
90 Oliva Serie V Melanio Robusto Cigar Aficionado June 2013
90 Oliva Serie V Lancero Cigar Aficionado December 2010
90 Oliva Serie O Churchill Cigar Aficionado August 2008
90 Oliva Serie O Churchill Cigar Insider June 2008
90 Oliva Grand Cameroon Churchill Cigar Insider March 2006
90 Oliva Grand Cameroon Corna Grande Cigar Insider March 2006
90 Oliva Grand Cameroon Robusto Cigar Aficionado June 2005
90 Flor de Oliva 10th Anniversary Tordedo Cigar Insider Febrary 2005
89 Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro Cigar Aficionado January 2014
89 Oliva Serie V Belicoso Cigar Insider October 2013
89 Oliva Serie V Churchill Extra Cigar Insider October 2013
89 Oliva Serie V Double Toro Cigar Insider October 2013
89 Oliva Serie V Churchill Extra Cigar Insider August 2007
89 Oliva Serie V Lancero Cigar Insider August 2007
89 Oliva Serie V Special V Figuardo Cigar Insider August 2007
89 Oliva Special S Churchill Cigar Insider September 2006
89 Oliva Grand Cameroon Churchill Cigar Aficionado August 2006
89 Oliva Master Blend 2 Churchill Cigar Insider October 2005
89 Oliva Master Blend 2 Torpedo Cigar Insider October 2005
89 Oliva "O" Maduro Orion Cigar Insider July 2005
89 Oliva "O" Classic Omni Cigar Insider June 2005
89 Oliva "O" Classic Ovation Cigar Insider June 2005
89 Oliva "O" Olé Cigar Insider August 2002
89 Oliva "O" Oasis Cigar Insider August 2002
88 Oliva Serie O No. 4 Cigar Aficionado February 2010
 
Cigar Journal
5 Stars Oliva Serie V, Figurado Special View Rating Winter 2011
5 Stars Oliva Serie V, Figurado Special View Rating Summer 2010
5 Stars Oliva Serie V, Double Robusto View Rating Winter 2007
5 Stars Oliva Special S Diadema 7 x 48 View Rating Autumn 2006
4.5 Stars Oliva Serie O Corona View Rating Winter 2011
4.5 Stars Oliva V Churchill Extra View Rating Winter 2011
4.5 Stars Oliva Serie O Corona View Rating Summer 2009
4.5 Stars Oliva Serie O, No. 4 View Rating Winter 2007
4.5 Stars Oliva Serie G, Double Robusto View Rating Winter 2007
4 Stars Oliva Serie O Corona View Rating Winter 2010
4 Stars Oliva Serie V, Double Toro View Rating Winter 2009
4 Stars Oliva Serie G Robusto View Rating Spring 2009
4 Stars Oliva Connection Reserve Robusto View Rating Fall 2009
4 Stars Oliva Serie O View Rating Summer 2008
4 Stars Oliva Serie O, Toro View Rating Winter 2007
4 Stars Oliva Serie O Perfecto View Rating Autumn 2006
4 Stars Oliva Serie O No. 4 View Rating Spring 2007
3.5 Stars Oliva Connection Reserve Torpedo View Rating Spring 2010
3.5 Stars Oliva Serie O Robusto Maduro View Rating Autumn 2006
3.5 Stars Oliva Serie G Robusto Maduro View Rating Autumn 2006
3 Stars Oliva Serie G Belicoso View Rating Autumn 2006